I was in college when I first heard someone say that God has entrusted leadership of the local church to “elders.” While the suggestion seemed reasonable, it wasn’t clear to me that it was realistic for a congregation composed primarily of younger folks.
As it turns out, an “elder” in the New Testament is an office, not a life stage. Specifically, a local church’s elders—its pastors—are those within a congregation tasked with shepherding the flock (1 Pet 5:1–4). They are the leaders who must give an account to God for the church’s members (Heb 13:17).1 The NT is clear that these elders must meet certain qualifications—specifically, those listed in 1 Timothy 3:1–7 and Titus 1:5–9.
Yet pastors seeking to lead alongside a group of elders often find themselves in a difficult scenario: What if the church I pastor doesn’t have candidates who meet the qualifications for an elder? The answer: You train them.2
While there’s no one way to train elders, I offer six steps3 as a practical starting point for pastors to further customize according to their church’s specific needs and context.4
1. Identify character
The qualifications for elders (1 Tim 3:1–7; Titus 1:5–9) demand both character and competence. While we should be willing to train the latter to a certain degree (e.g., able to teach), the former must be there from day 1.
Mr. Jones might be particularly influential in the congregation and have great leadership skills, but if he is not “above reproach” (1 Tim 3:2),5 then he is not ready for elder candidacy. Keep in mind that it’s Christ’s church, not yours. You must fight the temptation to let giftedness outweigh godliness. Rather, seek out those whose life of faith will serve as an example to the flock (1 Pet 5:3).
Oftentimes, these people are already serving in the church in some capacity. Thus, it’s often wise to begin searching for elder candidates among those who are already exercising their gifts and whose commitment to the body demonstrates a concern for the congregation at large.
2. Initiate the conversation
After identifying potential candidates, sit down with each one and express your desire for them to consider elder training. Make sure to explain the duration of the training (ours is two years)6 and the time commitment it will require.
Don’t be surprised if they are initially reluctant. It’s possible that they’ve never even considered being a “pastor.” Explain to them that the Bible doesn’t require seminary-trained professionals to shepherd the church. Affirm that you believe they have the character required of the office (and that you’ll help develop the skills).
Having made these clarifications, remember that God doesn’t want reluctant undershepherds: “The saying is trustworthy: If anyone aspires to the office of overseer, he desires a noble task” (1 Tim 3:1). While wisdom is required to discern between a genuine lack of desire and an initial lack of self-confidence, avoid pressuring those who simply aren’t interested (e.g., “I honestly have no desire to be in a leadership role”).
Ask those who do show interest to commit the decision to prayer. Set a date to follow up. Ensure that those who are married include their wives in the discernment process.7 It’s crucial that candidates’ wives understand the time commitment and sacrifice that eldering often requires. While the NT offers no qualifications for elders’ wives, a wife who doesn’t wholeheartedly support her husband serving in a pastoral role can be a liability to his ministry—and, consequently, the church—in the long run.
3. Screen with a questionnaire
Those who decide to begin elder candidacy are ready to fill out the onboarding questionnaire, which is extensive and invasive by design. To encourage transparency, we make sure candidates understand that not knowing the answer to a theological question or admitting past moral failure is not an automatic disqualification. At this point, we’re simply trying to learn more about their beliefs and life of faith.
It’s important to explore a wide range of issues—doctrine, ethics, personal life, skills, etc.—in order to discern whether or not a candidate will fit well within your leadership structure. As you construct your survey, consider dividing your questions into categories to make things more manageable. Below are example questions for each of the three categories we use in our questionnaire.
Personal life and spiritual background
- Tell us about how you became a Christian. Along the way, tell us about any churches you have been involved with and what impact those seasons had on your spiritual development.
- Describe your practice of the spiritual disciplines. Include in particular your practice of Bible reading and prayer.
- Describe how you are intentional about making disciples and developing relationships with unbelievers. When was the last time you shared the gospel with an unbeliever?
- Are you now or have you ever been under professional care for mental or emotional hardship? If yes, please explain.
- How would you describe the current health of your marriage (if married)? What are its strengths and weaknesses?
- To what extent have you been involved with pornography (including cable channels, soft-core porn, internet porn, magazines), strip clubs, etc.?
Doctrinal and personal convictions
- Who have been your primary theological teachers or influences? Include any authors, theologians (living or dead), movements, denominations, schools of thought, or podcasts that have most influenced your theological and biblical understanding.
- What do you believe about the Bible? What is it and how does it relate to your life?
- Describe your doctrine of justification—what is it and how is one justified?
- What does it mean that the human being is made in the imago Dei (i.e., image of God)?
- What is a church? What is the mission of the church (i.e., its primary task)?
- What is the purpose and function of baptism? Its proper mode? Its proper recipients? Who can baptize?
- Do you hold any theological positions that you believe stand outside the norm at our church or are simply strange or unorthodox? Are you passionate about niche theological/ethical issues (e.g., age of the earth, specific Bible translations)? Please explain.
Pastoral theology and practice
- How would you respond pastorally to a couple at church who call you and tell you in tears that they miscarried nine weeks into pregnancy?
- A college student is struggling to set physical boundaries with his girlfriend. He asks, “How far is too far before marriage?” How would you respond?
- Someone in your small group tells you in confidence that they experience same-sex attraction. How would you respond?
- After a Sunday service, a young married man comes to you and asks you to pray for him regarding his porn addiction. What would you do? How would you counsel this man on the spot?
After giving candidates plenty of time to complete the questionnaire (we give ours three months), your current leadership will need to carefully review their submissions and follow up with any additional questions or concerns. Once you are comfortable with a candidate’s answers, they are ready to begin formal training.
4. Provide doctrinal instruction
At our church, the first year of training is focused on theology in order to equip candidates “to give instruction in sound doctrine and also to rebuke those who contradict it” (Titus 1:9).
We’ve found that it works well to work through a systematic theology text—along with related, supplemental material—and to meet once a month for dinner to discuss the reading.8 Homework for a training session might look something like this, using Wayne Grudem’s Systematic Theology (Zondervan, 2020) as an example:
- Read chapter 1.
- In your own words, what is theology? What is Christian theology?
- How would you respond to someone who says, “I’m more of a doer than a thinker. Theology is for academics”?
- In your opinion, what is the best point Carl Trueman makes in his Themelios article, “The Importance of Not Studying Theology”?
- Read The Chicago Statement on Biblical Inerrancy. Do you have any objections or questions? In function, what constitutes a denial of inerrancy (e.g., is theistic evolution a denial of inerrancy)?
- Read Keith Mathison’s Modern Reformation piece, “Solo Scriptura: The Difference a Vowel Makes.” Come prepared to discuss the question, “What is the proper role of tradition in theology?”
Feel free to mix up the homework: Include videos (we have our candidates watch a few debates and lectures), give candidates a task (e.g., share the gospel with a co-worker) that you’ll review together, and invite fellow pastors/scholars to lead discussions on issues within their specialization.
5. Offer practical ministry experience
In the second year of elder training, we focus on applied ministry.
While we continue to meet monthly to discuss reading related to practical shepherding—marriage, conflict resolution, preaching, counseling, etc.—we begin by giving candidates reps in a variety of public ministry settings. Here we give specific attention to observing and developing their public ministry of the Word in a variety of settings:
- Ordinances—Give candidates opportunities to baptize and officiate the table.
- Preaching—Help them develop a sermon manuscript and allow them to fill the pulpit. Have them watch their sermon afterward. Offer constructive criticism.
- Small groups—Assign candidates to lead Bible studies and/or Sunday school classes.
- Marriages/funerals/hospital visits—Ask them to participate in significant moments in the lives of members of the congregation.
- Liturgy—Allow candidates to lead corporate prayer and responsive readings, and to offer benedictions in corporate worship.
Not only does giving elder candidates experience and feedback help them develop their ministry skills, but it also prepares the congregation to affirm their leadership.
While there is disagreement on the scope of what “able to teach” (1 Tim 3:2) requires (e.g., corporate teaching, small groups, one-on-one), fight the temptation to move forward with candidates whom you judge to be unfit in this area. While it might require an uncomfortable conversation and further development, installing an elder who isn’t able to teach—however you define it—not only ignores the plain teaching of Scripture but also hurts the church in the long run.
6. Install new elders publicly
Candidates who satisfy your training requirements are ready to be publicly affirmed by the congregation. While ecclesial traditions have different ordination formats, at a bare minimum, a congregation should formally acknowledge and celebrate its new leaders. At our church, we set aside a Sunday evening to present and ordain new elders.
Your installation service may include any number of elements:
- A brief teaching on the nature and responsibilities of the office
- A charge to the incoming elders
- A personal word of affirmation for each elder (consider inviting candidates’ longtime friends or mentors to offer a word of encouragement)
- A word from married candidates’ wives testifying to their husbands’ leadership in the home
- A congregational response of endorsement and submission to their new leaders
- A laying on of hands and prayer of committal
Conclusion
Whether you’re looking to add to a strong elder team or create one, there’s hardly an investment that yields more dividends than developing elders who will “shepherd the flock of God that is among you, exercising oversight, not under compulsion, but willingly, as God would have you; not for shameful gain, but eagerly” (1 Pet 5:2).
If you desire more elders, don’t wait for seminary-trained individuals to walk through the door. Develop them from your own membership. Doing so not only prepares them for the “noble task” of overseeing the church (1 Tim 3:1), but it also cultivates the health of the congregation by multiplying shepherds who will sacrificially labor among its members (1 Thess 5:12) as those who will give an account (Heb 13:17).
Chase Krug’s recommended resources for further reflection
- Newton, Phil A., and Matt Schmucker. Elders in the Life of the Church: Rediscovering the Biblical Model for Church Leadership. 9Marks Life in the Church. Kregel Ministry, 2014.
Related content
- Unpacking Elders & Deacons, Shepherds & Servants of the Church
- 7 Steps to Identify & Raise Up Future Pastors
- What Your Church Needs to Train Leaders (You Probably Already Have It)
- Want to Build a Pastoral Internship? 4 Steps
- Church Leadership Training: 5 Qualities Every Leader Needs
- While I will refer to the office of “elder,” “overseer,” and “pastor” interchangeably (in keeping with my own convictions), other ecclesiastical traditions make distinctions between these offices. For a discussion of different polities, see Chad Owen Brand and R. Stanton Norman, eds., Perspectives on Church Government: Five Views of Church Polity (B&H Academic, 2004).
- Crucially, while formal theological training is a tremendous asset in ministry, never does the NT outsource training pastors to seminaries. Rather, elders are usually appointed from among the congregation. Thus, rather than waiting for a stable of MDivs to join the church, pastors must take the initiative to develop elders from among their membership.
- These steps can be grouped into three main phases: (1) selection, (2) training, and (3) affirmation.
- Among the many resources for pastoral training available, Phil Taylor’s Eldership Development: From Application to Affirmation, Backstage Pastors Series 2 (Floodlight, 2017), has had the most enduring impact on our church’s approach to developing elders. In this article, I provide our version of Taylor’s template.
- All Bible quotations are from the ESV unless otherwise stated.
- We allow those with a Bible degree to complete both training years concurrently.
- Although many Christians disagree on this topic, I’m speaking here from my own convictions that the office of elder is to be reserved for men. For further resources and perspectives on this topic, see James R. Beck, ed., Two Views on Women in Ministry (Zondervan, 2005); and Bonnidell Clouse and Robert G. Clouse, eds., Women in Ministry: Four Views (InterVarsity, 1989).
- If you belong to the Reformed tradition, as I do, then there are a number of helpful one-volume systematic theologies to choose from. See Wayne Grudem, Systematic Theology: An Introduction to Biblical Doctrine, 2nd ed. (Zondervan, 2020); Joel Beeke and Paul M. Smalley, Essentials of Reformed Systematic Theology (Crossway, 2025); Millard J. Erickson, Christian Theology, 3rd ed. (Baker Academic, 2013); and Louis Berkhof, Systematic Theology, exp. ed. (Banner of Truth, 2021).
