Old Historians, New Historians, No Historians: The Derailed Debate on the Genesis of Israel

by Raphael Israeli

Publisher:

Wipf and Stock

, 2016

Overview

This polemical volume tackles the thorny and controversial issue of the vastly different narratives told (or manufactured) by the two parties of the conflict in the Middle East (the Arabs and Israel), focusing on 1948, where it all started. While all sides in this debate have vested interests, this author included, an attempt has been made here to reflect the factual truth on the events, although their interpretation will always remain controversial. Although the book argues principally with Benny Morris, the founder and leader of the so-called New Historians, it encompasses a wide array of controversial topics, like the evaluation of the 1948-49 War, the morality of the war (or the necessity to wage it as it was), and its main reverberations, such as the continuing conflict after seven decades, the aggravation of the Palestinian minority in Israel, and the essence of what history means. Israeli argues that the current debate between the so-called Old Historians and the New Historians--itself healthy if and when it is kept to the point and not allowed to degrade into personal libel and recriminations--is not really as unbridgeable as is often claimed. Both sides have erred at points and both sides have some important and complementary light to shed on the contentious events surrounding the birth of Israel.

Key Features

Praise for Old Historians, New Historians, No Historians

”Israeli is exceptionally distinguished by his independent thinking, rigorous research, and compelling writing style. In this new and highly germane volume, he surveys competing historical presentations of Zionism and Israel’s founding, as a backdrop to the nagging question of the legitimacy of the reconstituted Jewish state. Israeli’s readiness to jump into the intellectual and political arena--and offer a cogent historical scrutiny--provides a major contribution to the interested readership and public."
--Mordechai Nisan, The Hebrew University of Jerusalem 

“Israeli has published a monumental account on Israel’s right to exist as any other nation in the world. The debate within the small circle of Israeli historians on this subject is portrayed in detail against the background of the intensifying ideological battle between the liberal West and jihadist Islam. Israeli offers a new path, namely a rethinking of Jordan as the future Palestinian homeland, which offers a more realistic prospect to implement the Palestinians’ right to self-determination."
--Marc Cogen, Professor of International Law, Brussels

Product Details

• Title : Old Historians, New Historians, No Historians: The Derailed Debate on the Genesis of Israel
• Author: Israeli, Raphael
• Publisher: Wipf and Stock
• Publication Date: 2016
• ISBN: 9781498279192

About Raphael Israeli

Raphael Israeli is professor of Chinese history and Islamic civilization at the Hebrew University, Jerusalem. He is the author of A Critical Biography of Chinese Islam and Fundamentalist Islam and Israel.